Consider this situation: You are caring for a hungry girl whom you can’t afford to feed. What do you do? Do you steal food, or do you let her starve in the name of law and order?
For many people, thorny ethical questions can be difficult to swallow. For one nonprofit in Michigan, USA, and the Rotarians who support it, moral ambiguity is a dish best served with a cold beer.
In February, A2Ethics.org hosted the third annual Big Ethical Question Slam at Conor O’Neill’s Irish Pub in Ann Arbor, drawing a diverse crowd of students, retirees, professionals, and academics to weigh life’s dilemmas over a few pints.
An entertaining dilemma
During this spin-off of a pub trivia night or poetry slam, teams compete by responding to hypothetical questions drawn from a hat. Subjects include the theoretical -- How do we quantify ethical dilemmas? -- and the topical -- Can doping athletes like Lance Armstrong redeem themselves? -- with some broaching sensitive territory -- Should drone warfare be prohibited on moral grounds? A three-judge panel critiques and rates the teams’ two-minute responses, while about 75 onlookers fill out scorecards to determine the “people’s choice.”
“We conceived of the slam as a ‘think-off’ version of ‘Dancing With the Stars’or ‘American Idol,’” explains Jeanine DeLay, president of A2Ethics, which aims to promote ethics through education, social networking, and community events. (A2 is a nickname for Ann Arbor.) “We didn’t want it to be too highbrow. The point is to engage people in ethics discussions in a fun way.”
“Rotarians look to The Four-Way Test when we’re ethically evaluating whether to do something, but people come from different perspectives and have their own moral yardsticks,” says Karen Kerry, one of several Rotarians in the audience at Conor O’Neill’s. Kerry is the 2014-15 president of the Rotary Club of Ann Arbor, which hopes to enter a team in the next contest.
“People have gotten away from this long history of gathering in places for issue-based discussions: The Greeks had their acropolis, and the Romans had their forum. At least we can do it here in our Irish pub.” Kerry’s husband, Brad Chick, an Internet entrepreneur and former philosophy student, agreed to be a judge for the competition.
Asking the tough questions
The atmosphere in the bar is congenial; after all, it’s a snowy Thursday night in a college-town pub. People whisper to one another and jot down notes over fish and chips. Erin Mattimoe, an A2Ethics board member and the evening’s master of ceremonies, keeps the crowd on task as she reads the question at hand, anonymously submitted through the organization’s website before the event: In an election, is it unethical to vote for a candidate you feel isn’t qualified -- if you agree on one key issue?
Teri Turner steps up to the microphone as the sounds of conversation and clinking glasses fade. She represents a team of staff from the Center for Bioethics and Social Sciences in Medicine at the University of Michigan Medical School. “I would argue that voting on one key issue is not unethical,” she says. “For example, I might be a pacifist who does not want her children to go to war, and I might find a candidate who’s unacceptable in every way except that he’s antiwar.”
“Having spent most of my life voting for the lesser of two evils, I think that was a great answer,” responds judge Peter Jacobson with a laugh. “Nicely argued.” Jacobson is a professor of health law and policy at the University of Michigan and director of the Center for Law, Ethics, and Health at the School of Public Health.
A showcase for new ideas
Teams come from a range of institutions and groups, including a liberal-arts-focused prep school, an integrated marketing communications agency, the clinical research administration program at Eastern Michigan University, and the League of Women Voters of the Ann Arbor Area, a nonpartisan political organization that promotes civic engagement.
“Bringing together this many people to talk about ethically focused questions -- all from different backgrounds, from organizations with different mission statements -- you’re going to hear something new,” Mattimoe says.
“The slam gives people who are not in the same professional orbit a chance to come together for an evening and talk in a setting that isn’t confrontational, that doesn’t encourage taking sides,” DeLay says. “We’re providing a new showcase to people like Rotarians who are working to make their communities places that value, support, and celebrate ethics and civic-minded practices.”
By Jennifer Conlin. Additional reporting by Sallyann Price
Adapted from a story in the August 2013 issue of The Rotarian
Sir Emeka Offor likes to describe himself simply: He is the son of a policeman, born in the small town of Kafanchan, Nigeria. It is a way of reminding himself of his humble origins. Offor – who worked his way up to become executive vice chair of the Chrome Group, a multibillion-dollar oil and gas conglomerate, and who founded the Sir Emeka Offor Foundation, whose mission is to create economic opportunities in Nigeria’s poor communities – prefers to let his work and philanthropy speak for him. And with his most recent gift of $1 million to PolioPlus, Offor adds another achievement to his story: He is Africa’s single largest donor to Rotary.
“My dad had to make many sacrifices,” says Offor, a member of the Rotary Club of Awka G.R.A. “I decided I must support the underprivileged in society – the people who are not able to afford three square meals, or the people who can’t go to school.”
The effects of polio are still evident in Offor’s community: Nigeria is one of three remaining polio-endemic countries, and although it has made strides, the work of eradication has been challenging.
“At times the progress is slow,” Offor says. “But it is my deepest hope that we can inspire all Nigerians to work together to bring about the final, permanent, and irreversible eradication of polio.”
The 20 top high school teams in Wisconsin will compete at the 31st Annual State Competition on March 13-14, 2014. Volunteers receive online instructions, an on-site orientation, meal & free parking.
Note all assignments take place in Wisconsin Dells, except for Essay reading.
A shuttle bus will be provided for Speech and Interview volunteers on March 13. The bus will depart from the west side of Madison @ 2:15 P.M. and return from the Dells at approximately 10:00 P.M.
Over 100 volunteers are needed – Be a part of this outstanding academic venue. Experience the intensity, determination and excitement of competition.
Speech Judges: 15 Pairs of judges (30 total judges needed from 4:00-8:40 P.M. on March 13). Listen, critique and grade the students’ prepared and impromptu speeches. A Judges’ Handbook is provided along with a brief orientation on the day of the event. A background in public speaking, or affiliation with Toastmasters a plus. Dinner included.
Speech Timers: Stationed in each speech room (15 needed from 4:00-8:40 P.M. on March 13). Monitor and time each student’s speech. Written directions are provided and a brief orientation takes place on the day of the event. Comfort with a stop watch is necessary. Dinner included.
Interview Judges: 15 Pairs of judges (30 total judges needed from 4:00-8:40 P.M. on March 13). Jointly interview students; guidelines and sample questions are provided in the Judges’ Handbook in addition to a brief orientation on the day of the event. A background in Human Resources a plus. Dinner included
Essay Judges: : Essay rubric is outlined in the Judges’ Handbook; 18 volunteers will read and critique essays written prior to the State Event — Judges will gather on Thursday, March 6 from 1:00 - 4:00 P.M. at First Realty, Madison, WI. A background in English or editing is helpful.
Effective February 1st, the new bulletin editor will be Laurie Ellis-McLeod. Please send your articles to Laurie. She will also be responsible for scheduling the greeters, treasurer assistants, etc...
On September 11, 2001, Todd Shea found himself running toward ground zero. He had no business being there. A singer-songwriter with a record deal, Shea should have been prepping for a gig at CBGB, one of New York City's most iconic venues. Instead he was using his band's van to bring food, water, and supplies to first responders.
After five grueling days amid the rubble of the Twin Towers, Shea decided to sacrifice his musical career, and dedicate his life to disaster relief.
"Seeing the suffering in New York opened my eyes to what other people around the world are going through every day,"...
Maya Ajmera founded the Global Fund for Children in 1993 to provide seed money to community-based organizations that help at-risk children across the world. Since then, GFC has awarded more than $32 million in grants to over 600 organizations in 80 countries, improving the lives of millions of children – from educating AIDS orphans in Uganda to conducting so-called curbside classrooms for waste pickers in Cambodia.
"Education is the key to getting human beings out of poverty," says Ajmera, whose studies at St. Xavier's College in Mumbai were sponsored by the Rotary Club of China Lake in...
Dennis Ogbe grips the discus in his right hand. He swings his arm and twists at the waist as far to the right as he can. With one move he snaps back, letting the saucer fly. Upper-body strength is important for any discus thrower, but for Ogbe, a Paralympian, it’s everything.
At age three, Ogbe contracted malaria, and while receiving treatment at a clinic near his home in rural Nigeria, he became infected with the poliovirus. Paralyzed from the waist down, he was sent home in the arms of his mother.
He credits his physical rehabilitation to a harsh form of therapy – the taunts of the other...
In Tamil Nadu, India, two doctors, both members of the Rotary Club of Srirangam, discovered an alarming trend in the remote city outskirts of Trichy, women dying of breast cancer.
Drs. K. Govindaraj and K.N. Srinivasan knew that much of the death and suffering could be avoided, and both were motivated by their personal experiences with the disease. Govindaraj watched his mother die of breast cancer a decade earlier, and helped found the Dr. K. Shantha Breast Cancer Foundation in her memory. Srinivasan, an oncologist, witnessed unprecedented growth in the number of younger patients coming to...
